Tylar Witt resided in El Dorado Hills, California, with her mother, Joanne Witt, who worked as an assistant engineer for the county’s Department of Transportation. Joanne, aged 47, was dedicated to providing for her daughter, ensuring she had access to various activities like riding lessons and shared interests such as cooking and watching movies.
At 14 years old and on the brink of starting high school, Tylar met Steven Colver, a 19-year-old, whom she viewed as her modern-day Romeo. The relationship between Tylar and Colver turned tumultuous when Joanne threatened to report Colver for statutory rape. Feeling trapped like Shakespeare’s tragic lovers, Tylar and Colver soon took drastic actions.
In a shocking twist, Joanne was found stabbed to death on June 11, 2009, by none other than her own daughter and boyfriend. The events leading up to this tragedy were marred by Tylar’s infatuation with Colver, leading them down a dark path of drug use and risky behavior.
Their relationship was exposed when Joanne found Tylar and Colver in a compromising situation. Despite Joanne’s efforts to end the relationship and protect her daughter, Tylar and Colver continued their forbidden romance. Joanne’s discovery of Tylar’s diary detailing their illicit affair ultimately led to the fatal confrontation.
Following Joanne’s murder, Tylar and Colver attempted to flee but were eventually apprehended after confessing their crime to a friend. Both were charged with murder, leading to a courtroom showdown where Tylar testified against Colver, resulting in a revised charge for her.
During the trial, details emerged of the gruesome crime scene and the chilling confession from both perpetrators. Colver, known as “Boston,” described the night of the murder, painting a haunting picture of the events that transpired.
Ultimately, Colver was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life without parole. Tylar, on the other hand, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and received a prison sentence of 15 years to life. After serving her time, she was granted parole in 2022 and released a year later.
The tragic story of manipulation, drugs, and twisted love ended in a courtroom, where justice was served for the heinous crime committed by Tylar Witt and Steven Colver in El Dorado Hills, California.