During the federal election last year, Donald Trump’s threats regarding tariffs and his comments about turning Canada into the 51st state created a surprising turn of events in Quebec: discussions about safeguarding the province’s interests were overshadowed by the need to defend Canada from its neighbor.
On election day, Mark Carney’s Liberals took advantage of this sentiment, achieving the party’s strongest performance in the province in many years and relegating the Bloc Québécois to the background.
Discussions surrounding Quebec’s identity, secularism, and language were drowned out by the clamor coming from Washington.
As the provincial election kicks off today, could the U.S. president again play such a significant role?
The recently imposed tariffs have dominated conversations in the lead-up to the campaign’s start, pressuring every party leader to demonstrate their ability to protect the province from the economic repercussions.
“It appears that managing the economy in these uncertain times could be the decisive issue at the ballot box,” Philippe Fournier, a polling analyst and founder of the website Qc125, shared with CBC News.
Trade war and beyond
Prior to the escalation of the trade war, surveys indicated that voters were most concerned about issues like healthcare, housing, and the cost of living.
In this context, the Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) faces a challenging situation after two terms in office and a dissatisfied electorate, according to André Lecours, a political science professor at the University of Ottawa.
The CAQ stands to benefit the most if economic stability becomes a priority for voters, he noted.
“Almost instantly, the pivotal question shifted from ‘How do you evaluate the past eight years of government?’ to ‘Who do you trust to navigate this crisis?’” Lecours explained.
A recent analysis by Oxford Economics indicates that Quebec is one of the provinces facing the most significant impacts from the new tariffs, mainly due to its heavy dependence on exports in the automotive, metals, and manufacturing sectors.
-
Quebec party leaders make their pitches as election campaign kicks off
-
Trump says idea of him interfering with Canadians speaking French is a ‘stupid thing’
Paul St-Pierre Plamondon, whose Parti Québécois (PQ) is currently leading in opinion polls, attempted to neutralize the situation last week by stating he would not initiate a referendum until after Trump’s second term in office.
“This election focuses on Quebec and what is necessary for its future,” St-Pierre Plamondon told reporters.
Nonetheless, recent surveys indicate a tightening race, with the CAQ, which has been trailing behind the PQ and Liberals for several months, starting to gain momentum.
Drawing parallels to Carney
CAQ Leader Christine Fréchette benefits from her position in power amid the turmoil.
She appeared alongside Prime Minister Mark Carney on two occasions in the weeks leading up to the election, first to announce the Churchill Falls energy agreement and again on Tuesday for the unveiling of $11 billion in funding for six new icebreakers constructed in Quebec.
Fréchette also introduced two new financial assistance programs aimed specifically at small and medium-sized enterprises in the manufacturing and primary sectors that are most affected by the tariffs.
-
Will the PQ’s Trump-era referendum pause work with voters?
-
Homelessness, mobility, public safety atop Montreal’s wish list ahead of Quebec election
The CAQ hopes Fréchette can emulate Carney’s rise after taking charge of an unpopular governing party.
However, Fournier remarked that the comparison falters quickly — Carney’s popularity provided an immediate boost to the Liberals, while the CAQ has not experienced the same sustained improvement under Fréchette.
Additionally, he pointed out, there is no counterpart to Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, who was “perceived as resembling Trump.”
Parties present their arguments
Fréchette’s opponents are already working to undermine the notion that she is the best candidate to navigate the current situation.
St-Pierre Plamondon criticized Fréchette for being disconnected from the federal government’s negotiation strategies and accused her of failing to safeguard Quebec’s interests. Charles Milliard, the leader of the Quebec Liberals, stated that his party would be better positioned to establish stronger ties with the federal government and other provinces.
Meanwhile, Québec Solidaire has suggested a $1 billion annual “Trump fund” to directly assist affected workers and businesses, while Éric Duhaime’s Conservatives are promising $47 billion in cuts to spending and tax relief.
“The leader who can capture the electorate and declare, ‘I am the steady hand at the helm amidst the storm brought by Donald Trump, the tariffs, and the uncertainty,’ will likely have the advantage,” Fournier stated.
“However, it remains unclear who that leader will be.”
